Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Court: Family mistakenly notified of woman’s death can’t sue

April "Abby" Guerra speaks to reporters in Phoenix Friday, May 8, 2015. In 2010, Arizona Department of Public Safety officers told her parents in that Abby, then 19, had been killed in a rollover car accident. Maria and Jose Guerra spent six days thinking their daughter was dead when instead it was one of her friends who died. The Guerras sued for negligence, saying the officer owed a duty of care to ensure they had correctly identified the victim. The Arizona Supreme Court ruled Friday, May 8, 2015 that the family can't sue the state, saying imposing such a duty could cause officers to delay next-of-kin notifications.(Matthew Casey/Arizona Republic via AP)
April "Abby" Guerra speaks to reporters in Phoenix Friday, May 8, 2015. In 2010, Arizona Department of Public Safety officers told her parents in that Abby, then 19, had been killed in a rollover car accident. Maria and Jose Guerra spent six days thinking their daughter was dead when instead it was one of her friends who died. The Guerras sued for negligence, saying the officer owed a duty of care to ensure they had correctly identified the victim. The Arizona Supreme Court ruled Friday, May 8, 2015 that the family can't sue the state, saying imposing such a duty could cause officers to delay next-of-kin notifications.(Matthew Casey/Arizona Republic via AP)

PHOENIX (AP) – For six days, the family of 19-year-old April Guerra mourned her death because they thought she was killed in a car wreck. It turns out, she wasn’t.

Arizona’s highest court said Friday the family cannot sue the state for negligence after officers mistakenly told them Guerra died in a 2010 rollover crash west of Phoenix.

The officers confused Guerra’s identity with that of a close friend who did die in the Interstate 10 wreck. That woman’s parents stood vigil with a paralyzed and badly bruised Guerra, thinking she was their daughter, for nearly a week.

Then a medical examiner confirmed it was 21-year-old Marlena Cantu in the morgue and Guerra, who went by the name Abby, in the Phoenix hospital.

The Guerras sued, arguing Department of Public Safety officers owed them a duty to ensure they properly identified the victim before telling the family their daughter was dead.