Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

An epic health care battle

The Affordable Care Act has just turned two years old, yet tomorrow begins the Supreme Court challenge that will determine whether the ACA lives and thrives, or shrivels, or dies. For all the ways that it would secure the promise of affordable, comprehensive health care for most all Americans, it is regrettable — indeed, almost incomprehensible — that the ACA faces this legal battle.

As the huge stakes in this lawsuit suggest, however, the battle will be epic, a rarity for the decades. While the Supreme Court customarily allots just an hour for the cases it hears, it has set aside three days for hearings on the ACA. A big chunk of that time will be devoted to the issue of constitutionality of the ACA’s mandate for all non-poor Americans to obtain insurance. Another will revolve around its severability clause, which, if upheld, would allow other parts of the law to remain in force even if the purchase mandate was found to be impermissible under federal interstate commerce precedents.

This battle was always predictable. Republicans fought tooth-and-nail to defeat the creation of the nation’s two other vital leavening social benefits — Social Security and Medicare. Their fight to keep health care under the unbridled control of the nation’s most cold-blooded for-profit industries — the rich health insurance and pharmaceutical insurance industries which fill their campaign coffers — was to be expected.

The court has promised a ruling by the end of June, guaranteeing huge political ripples whatever the verdict.

If it goes in favor of the administration, Democrats would be able to build on the victory by implementing other major reforms and benefits that are set to take effect in 2014. Chief among these would be the establishment of regulated health insurance exchanges in every state that would allow for-profit companies to compete for customers under rules requiring comprehensive, no-exclusion plans that would limit companies over-head cost, require flat-rates for all customers, and set a floor on benefit provisions.