Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Book review: In ‘Sometimes You Have To Lie,’ Leslie Brody traces the origin story of an author and her fictional heroine

Seal Press / "Sometimes You Have To Life: The Life and Times of Louise Fitzhugh, Renegade Author of Harriet the Spy"
Seal Press / "Sometimes You Have To Life: The Life and Times of Louise Fitzhugh, Renegade Author of Harriet the Spy"
photo Seal Press / “Sometimes You Have To Life: The Life and Times of Louise Fitzhugh, Renegade Author of Harriet the Spy”

“SOMETIMES YOU HAVE TO LIE: THE LIFE AND TIMES OF LOUISE FITZHUGH, RENEGADE AUTHOR OF HARRIET THE SPY” by Leslie Brody (Seal Press, 352 pages, $30).

At first glance, Leslie Brody’s “Sometimes You Have To Lie” is an artist’s origin story – the biography of Louise Fitzhugh, dissident daughter of a powerful Memphis family who disavows the Jim Crow South, finds a new tribe of “successful, creative, pleasure-loving, ambitious, knowledgeable lesbians” (as a friend described them) in New York and Paris, and grows up to be a famous author.

Written in invisible ink, though, is a parallel message of hope and endurance for nonconformists seeking their own creative voices in a silencing world – much like Fitzhugh’s best-known work, the groundbreaking and subversive children’s best-seller, “Harriet the Spy.”

For bookish, spy-curious, and sporty Gen X girls like me, “Harriet the Spy” was a revelation. I had torn through the Hardy Boys books, but the poised and perfect Nancy Drew bored my eyes dry. Enter the deliciously imperfect sleuth-heroine Harriet M. Welsch, who wore her hair in a careless mop, practiced tradecraft in torn jeans and a hoodie, and expressed opinions with all-caps candor in a secret notebook.

By the early 1980s, when I read “Harriet,” the world had grown a bit less hostile to irreverent girls who preferred sneakers to ballet slippers. But in 1964, when the book came out, Harriet’s free-spirited delinquency was condemned by some “so-called children’s literature gatekeepers – librarians, teachers and members of parents’ associations, who considered themselves protectors of children’s welfare and arbiters of moral instruction,” writes Brody. Harriet wasn’t some adult’s notion of a role model for girls, which is probably why we loved her. And for young people discovering alternative expressions of gender and sexuality in a virulently homophobic society, it surely must have been a life preserver.