Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Jay Greeson: Football’s playoff plan still lacking

The group of college presidents approved the four-team playoff model this week. It will take affect in 2014, and there was mention of a 12-year commitment to this plan. You may have heard about it; it was in most of the papers.

Everyone wanted a playoff, yet this feels so anti-climatic, so disappointing. It’s like opening a sweater on Christmas. Sure it’s a gift and the thought was nice and appropriate, but where’s the X-Box games or a new Titleist pitching wedge.

College football fans opened a gift with the announcement of a four-team playoff on the horizon, but that gift was four teams too small. And 12 years? Really, 12 years? Sweet buckets, three presidential terms of snug sweaters and too tight decisions for a four-team draw.

Of course, it is fair to ask that if we wanted a playoff and are now unhappy with a playoff after about 14 hours after said playoff was announced then there’s no pleasing us. Well, it would be fair to ask that, but it would be wrong and misdirected.

A four-team playoff is simply the lords of college football’s manor giving the starving serfdom of fanhood a scrap from their table and expecting glorious applause of gratitude for their generosity. This is the worst type of plan; it’s doomed two years before it starts. And it quite possibly could do what, until this very moment, was deemed unthinkable — there’s a very real possibility that a four-team playoff could make fans long for the good-old days of the BCS.