Court ruling seems to go two ways
Surprisingly, Supreme Court Chief Justice Roberts, a Bush appointee, became the swing vote in favor of the Affordable Care Act.
I can’t take issue with much of the case law underlying the court’s decision. One question, though. How can the court rule the payment for not having required insurance is a penalty, not a tax (thus allowing the court to make a ruling by exempting it from the Anti-Injunction Act), while simultaneously ruling the mandate is constitutional by treating the payment as a tax under Article I of the Constitution rather than a coercion into a commercial transaction, and thus a violation under the court’s interpretation of the commerce clause? It seems the court has ruled the government can have its cake and eat it, too.
By the government’s argument (and the Supreme Court’s ruling), the ACA is in fact a tax, mainly one on the lower-income middle class who doesn’t carry health insurance and doesn’t qualify for government subsidies. How does President Obama justify the ACA with his campaign promise to not increase the tax burden on those in the middle class?
One thing I think we can all agree on: It will certainly be an interesting topic of discussion during this election season!
JOSH PAUL