Read more
Alstom tax break questioned: Chattanooga, Hamilton County mayors say company didn’t achieve jobs promise
Two very positive things happened this week in Chattanooga over what has been a prickly subject: payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreements known as PILOTs — the tax breaks that are often extended to expanding industries or property and housing developers.
Both of those names are misleading. They should be referred to as profits-in-lieu of taxes as they amount to years of tax-free status to whomever the city and county officials grant them.
Occastionally PILOTs make sense. Forgiving city and county property taxes and business taxes for a decade or two to help persuade Volkswagen to bring thousands of new jobs here was — to use a worn-out business phrase — a win-win.
But giving tax breaks to developers looking to turn an old warehouse or factory into apartments or forgiving a decade of taxes to a business that’s already been here for decades because it will expand enough to add several dozen more jobs needs to be looked at long and hard. Those forgone taxes mean fewer dollars to fix our roads, keep our parks in good repair and pay our police and firefighters. Routinely forgoing legitimate taxes for developers and manufacturers could all too easily result in tax increases for the rest of us.
