It was day two of the Battle of Gettysburg, the bloodiest fight of the American Civil War. Beneath a spiritless gray sky, amid the cries of thousands of boys and men, Union Gen. Daniel Sickles had just been hit by cannon fire. His right leg was fractured, eventually resulting in its amputation. As his men carried him to cover, a band of Confederate soldiers began advancing toward a stone fence at the edge of the wheat field. Without waiting for their officer’s command, they crossed it, pushing into a mob of bewildered Union soldiers.
Adrenaline pumping, the soldiers began to shove one another. Then, they began to throw punches.
This was not how it was supposed to happen.
“It was a spontaneous fist fight,” says Ben Rogers, a Civil War re-enactor with the Hardee Guard Battalion, a living history group based out of Tennessee, Alabama and Georgia. Though Rogers did not actually witness the unscripted brawl that took place between actors during this year’s Battle of Gettysburg re-enactment, his cousin David Thomas did.
The scuffle was brief, Thomas says. Officers quickly stepped between their men and directed them back to their side of the wall, which historically, the Confederates had not crossed. On the battlefield, Thomas says, re-enactors try to stay in character.
