Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Sohn: GOP health care plan is largely disaster care

Amy Kuiken, 34, of Dallas, Pa., holds her sign, as she listens during a town hall meeting regarding health care in Scranton, Pa., last month. House Republicans unveiled an ACA replacement plan Monday that critics say provides less coverage. (Butch Comegys/The Times & Tribune via AP)
Amy Kuiken, 34, of Dallas, Pa., holds her sign, as she listens during a town hall meeting regarding health care in Scranton, Pa., last month. House Republicans unveiled an ACA replacement plan Monday that critics say provides less coverage. (Butch Comegys/The Times & Tribune via AP)

As expected, Republicans and Donald Trump’s braggadocio claims to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act – aka Obamacare – with a better, more affordable health care plan was all talk and little planning.

On Monday, House Republicans unveiled their long-awaited, so-called plan, scrapping the mandate for most Americans to have health insurance in favor of a new system of tax credits intended to induce people to buy insurance on the open market.

There’s a big flaw there right up front. The working poor – the very folks the ACA was created for in the first place – usually don’t make enough money to actually pay for health care up front and wait to get the money back in tax refunds. Likewise, middle-income Americans won’t find the new plan particularly affordable if they’re forking over health-care money up front in hopes of getting a couple of thousand dollars back at tax time.

All this GOP bill does is provide a check mark for Republicans: Replacement for Obamacare so we can repeal it. And it’s a very poor excuse for a check mark, at that.

Meanwhile, it sets the stage for a certain and bitter debate over the possible dismantling of the most significant health care law in a half-century. In the ACA’s place would be a health law far more oriented to the free market (which isn’t free and isn’t fair).