Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Trial of ex-soccer coach accused of killing boy in NY starts

Oral "Nick" Hillary arrives at St. Lawrence County Courthouse on Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2016, in Canton, N.Y. The trial of the former college soccer coach accused of strangling his former girlfriend's 12-year-old son in October 2011 may result in a verdict, yet it will likely do little to quell the five-year controversy swirling in this rural village in northern New York. (Brit Hanson/North Country Public Radio via AP)
Oral "Nick" Hillary arrives at St. Lawrence County Courthouse on Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2016, in Canton, N.Y. The trial of the former college soccer coach accused of strangling his former girlfriend's 12-year-old son in October 2011 may result in a verdict, yet it will likely do little to quell the five-year controversy swirling in this rural village in northern New York. (Brit Hanson/North Country Public Radio via AP)

POTSDAM, N.Y. (AP) – The trial of a former college soccer coach accused of strangling his former girlfriend’s 12-year-old son in October 2011 starts this week and may result in a verdict, yet it will likely do little to quell the five-year controversy swirling in this rural village in northern New York.

Some in Potsdam see Oral “Nick” Hillary’s trial as a chance to finally bring a measure of justice for the family of Garrett Phillips. “Justice For Garrett” lawn signs still stand by roadsides and the case is still talked about often.

“It’s on our minds,” said Vikki Lavean, who works in Potsdam insurance office with a police flyer offering a reward for information in the case. “We feel bad for the family. Hopefully, the mother will get some closure.”

But critics see a largely white community railroading a black man. The critics point to a dismissed indictment, an oft-criticized district attorney and an apparent lack of physical evidence tying Hillary to the apartment.

After defense lawyers appeared in court in nearby Canton on Tuesday, they said the jury selection process scheduled to start Wednesday could stretch into next week as they filter out people who have signed petitions about the case or otherwise expressed opinions.