Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Mystery surrounds case of twins found dead, decomposed in Chattanooga home

mystery-surrounds-case-of-andrew-and-anthony
mystery-surrounds-case-of-andrew-and-anthony
Map

506 Acorn Street

506 Acorn Street
photo Grass grows through a crack in the sidewalk at 506 Acorn Court where the bodies of twin brothers Andrew and Anthony Johnson were found Sunday.

Three years before they found identical twins dead and decomposed, Chattanooga police officers showed up to the home of Andrew Garry Johnson and Anthony Larry Johnson.

Family members had called, according to a news release. They wanted to check on the twins, who this year would have turned 64. But outside 506 Acorn Court, police say, everything seemed OK in 2011.

Nobody had beaten the door down. The yard smelled fine. The U.S. Postal Service had placed a vacancy notice in the mailbox, which mailmen do whenever too many letters and bills pile up.

Perhaps the Johnson twins had moved away. If they had, family members apparently told police, the twins might have done so in secret.

“Andrew and Anthony lived a hermit lifestyle,” Chattanooga Police Department Public Information Officer Tim McFarland wrote in a news release Tuesday afternoon.