Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorney asks court to dismiss child death charges

The Hamilton County District Attorney’s office promised not to prosecute a young mother in relation to her child’s death if she took and passed a polygraph test, her attorney says.

But when Traci Carpenter did that, attorney Lee Davis asserts in court documents, prosecutors pursued her for two years on charges of aggravated child neglect that could land her in prison for at least 15 years if she is convicted.

Now Mr. Davis argues in court documents that the DA’s office had a duty to keep its promise. He will argue on July 27 in Hamilton County Criminal Court that charges against her should be dismissed.

He points to court documents stating that Ms. Carpenter would be charged with first-degree murder if she failed the polygraph. Mr. Davis says that proves she was willing to risk her freedom to help investigators catch the prime suspect in the death of 18-month-old Sierra Carpenter.

But in late 2008, a jury acquitted Ms. Carpenter’s ex-boyfriend, Brian Rutherford, of all charges including first-degree murder.