Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Tennessee Court of Appeals upholds dismissal of Democrats’ 2018 ballot challenge to now-Rep. Smith

Staff Photo by Robin Rudd / Tennessee Rep. Robin Smith answers a question. Members of the Hamilton County legislative delegation spoke to the Times Free Press at the newspaper's offices on Nov. 15, 2019.
Staff Photo by Robin Rudd / Tennessee Rep. Robin Smith answers a question. Members of the Hamilton County legislative delegation spoke to the Times Free Press at the newspaper's offices on Nov. 15, 2019.

NASHVILLE – The Tennessee Court of Appeals has unanimously upheld Hamilton County Chancellor Jeffrey Atherton’s dismissal of a 2018 lawsuit in which the state Democratic Party sought to knock then-Republican candidate Robin Smith off the ballot in the House District 26 contest.

In its unanimous decision, the appeals court ruled Friday the case was moot because of Smith’s subsequent election. It was the fourth ruling at the trial and appellate court level in two lawsuits filed on the controversy.

In the opinion, written by Judge Richard Dinkins and joined by Judges John McClarty and D. Michael Swiney, the court stated, “we have concluded that the requests for injunctive relief are moot because the actions sought to be enjoined have occurred, and that the request for declaratory judgment is moot because Ms. Smith was listed on the ballot and subsequently elected.

“Further,” the ruling added, “none of the exceptions to the mootness doctrine are present.” The judges noted a “moot case is one that has lost its justiciability because it no longer involves a present, ongoing controversy.”

The court also said it was denying a request for damages sought “for a frivolous appeal.”