Skip to main content
Saturday, October 31, 2026Oct 31

This story is free to read.

Modern mystery loosely based on Columbine shooting opens Friday in Chattanooga

Dawn Sheridan (played by Sally Peixoto, left), mother of a murdered girl, confronts survivor Caitlin Gabriel (played by Jamie McConnico) and her parents (played by Beth McClary and Greg Rambin) in the aftermath of a school shooting.
Dawn Sheridan (played by Sally Peixoto, left), mother of a murdered girl, confronts survivor Caitlin Gabriel (played by Jamie McConnico) and her parents (played by Beth McClary and Greg Rambin) in the aftermath of a school shooting. Dawn Sheridan (played by Sally Peixoto, left), mother of a murdered girl, confronts survivor Caitlin Gabriel (played by Jamie McConnico) and her parents (played by Beth McClary and Greg Rambin) in the aftermath of a school shooting.
photo Detective Washburn (played by Miracle Hurley, with back to camera) questions survivor Caitlin Gabriel (played by Jamie McConnico) about Caitlin’s every move the day of the shooting. In the background are Tim Newland, Sally Peixoto and Greg Rambin. All 10 actors are onstage throughout the play.

Cast and crew

Jamie McConnio (Caitlin Gabriel)Maggie Meller (Caitlin Gabriel)Beth McClary (Elizabeth Gabriel, her mother)Greg Rambin (Nolan Gabriel, her father)Sally Peixoto (Dawn Sheridan, mother of a victim killed in the shooting)Jeremy Campbell (Ryan Mayes, a witness to the shooting)Miracle Hurley (Detective Washburn)Tim Newland (Special Master Thorton)James Lawson (Father Dunston)Chen Zhang (Book Publisher)—Scott Dunlap (director)Thomas Alford (stage manager)

“The Library,” a modern mystery loosely based on the 1999 Columbine school shootings, opens Friday, Oct. 28, at the Chattanooga Theatre Centre.

The drama looks at what happens to the narrative as stories unfold in the wake of a tragedy.

“This is an exploration of the truth,” says director Scott Dunlap. “It’s about the definition of truth versus facts and how our perception becomes our truth.”

The story centers on Caitlin Gabriel (played at alternating performances by Maggie Meller and Jamie McConnico), who is accused of surviving the school shooting by betraying the hidden location of other students to the gunman. As she struggles to tell her truth, she finds that other stories have already gained hold in the media.

“This play is about the fallout of the event more than the event itself,” explains Dunlap. “It shows how, in our rush to get the story out, the reports become facts.”

The drama is spare and fast-paced, without excessive dialogue, more closely resembling an episode of “Law & Order” than a typical theatrical play, he says. There’s little background provided, so actors and audiences are left to imagine the backstories. Its 90-minute run time is presented without an intermission.

The pacing is due to playwright Scott Z. Burns’ deep experience in cinema – he is a writer producer of movies including “Contagion” and “The Bourne Ultimatum.”

“This play is, ultimately, a mystery, and we see it happening every day,” says Dunlap. “Whose story is true? Whom do we believe?”

Performances take place in the Mildred M. Montague Circle Theatre, which, for the first time in years, is set up for a true, theater-in-the-round performance.

If you go

› What: “The Library,” a Circle Theatre production.› When: Friday, Oct. 28-Sunday, Nov. 13.› Where: Chattanooga Theatre Centre, 400 River St.› Admission: $30 opening night, $12.50-$25 other nights.› Phone: 423-267-8534 (box office open 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Tuesday-Friday).› Website: TheatreCentre.comSpecial programming› Friday, Oct. 28: 8 p.m. curtain; cake and coffee with the cast after the performance› Saturday, Oct. 29: 8 p.m.› Thursday, Nov. 3: 7 p.m.; real-time captioning for hard-of-hearing patrons.› Friday, Nov. 4: 8 p.m.; ghost light Q&A with cast and director follows the performance› Saturday, Nov. 5: 8 p.m.› Sunday, Nov. 6: 2:30 p.m.› Thursday, Nov. 10: 7 p.m.› Friday, Nov. 11: 8 p.m.; Girls Night Out beginning at 7 p.m. with complimentary drinks and snacks› Saturday, Nov. 12: 8 p.m.› Sunday, Nov. 13: 2:30 p.m.