Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Sohn: Tennessee’s ‘super’ court idea is super GOP partisan

AP file photo by Mark Humphrey / Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Mike Bell, R-Riceville, leads a meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee last August in Nashville. Bell want to create a new "super" chancery court to hear state cases.
AP file photo by Mark Humphrey / Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Mike Bell, R-Riceville, leads a meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee last August in Nashville. Bell want to create a new "super" chancery court to hear state cases.

Trust our Tennessee legislators and governor to continue devising ways to ignore our votes and our wishes. This time, they want to thwart elected judges – whose decisions they don’t condone – by creating a kangaroo court of their own liking. They have dubbed their would-be proxy as a statewide “super” chancery court.

This would be a three-judge panel – first appointed by Gov. Lee and later elected – that would hear all constitutional challenges to state laws. To the tune of $2 million a year, this new court would essentially duplicate a system of Tennessee chancery courts that have been handling state and local business for a century and a half.

Why do our GOP-majority lawmakers and governor want to do this? Politics, of course. Partisan politics.

The bill of Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Mike Bell, R-Riceville, this measure is a response to constitutional challenges that have not gone in Republicans’ favor over the past few years. Lee’s education savings account program and Republicans’ fetal heartbeat law are two examples. So, too, was the ruling about absentee balloting last fall during concerns about the spread of COVID-19.

Republicans don’t like the fact that already-elected judges in Nashville, with one of the most liberal voting constituencies in the state, are by virtue of jurisdiction most often the courts where these cases are heard. And the Davidson County chancellors haven’t decided cases the way the super-majority, super-conservative Republican legislators would like.