Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Matinee Melee: ‘Iron Man 2’ brilliant but not as good as the original

CASEY PHILLIPS: In 2008, Robert Downey Jr.’s performance in “Iron Man” left no doubt he was destined to play reformed playboy-turned-hero Tony Stark. In this second outing, Stark retains his zest for life as he shoulders the weight of heroic responsibility and public scrutiny while donning a suit that’s slowly killing him. Downey has incorporated these elements as counterpoints that really add dimension to the role.

Downey is joined by a host of effectively cast new faces. Sam Rockwell is brilliant and hilarious as Justin Hammer, one of Stark’s jealous competitors. Speaking of which, Zoe Saldana finally has competition for Queen of the Geeks in a black-leather-clad Scarlett Johansson, who oozes ice-cold sex appeal as Natasha “Black Widow” Romanoff. Don Cheadle is a fine James “War Machine” Rhodes. He has a more significant role than Terrence Howard did, but I would have preferred casting consistency there.

HOLLY LEBER: “Iron Man 2” was almost awesome enough to make me not feel annoyed about being something of an outsider, as I’m not a comic-book aficionado (read: mega nerd) like my esteemed friend and colleague, but I’m really, really sick of franchise movies.

Despite that fact, I’m not sorry I went. This movie kicks some serious … derriere. The energy is high, the special effects are fun and the fight scenes get the adrenaline pumping. There’s a lot of humor as well. Downey is especially funny as Stark, who is really quite unlikable in a lot of ways, but you still really root for him. And Mickey Rourke, despite a questionable Russian accent and appalling coiffure, is a bad… all right, this movie does not conjure up finishing-school vocabulary, but if you’ve seen the scene in the trailer where he’s brandishing flashing energy whips, you know what I mean.