Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Family of man killed in 2019 deputy-involved shooting files $20 million lawsuit

A Hamilton County Sheriff's Office vehicle is seen at the scene of a shooting on the 9100 block of Broyles Drive on Tuesday, April 9, 2019 in Chattanooga, Tenn.

A man is dead after an officer-involved shooting early Tuesday morning. 

Shortly after midnight, three Hamilton County deputies responded to a home in the 9100 block of Broyles Drive in East Brainerd on reports of a "disorderly subject," according to a Tennessee Bureau of Investigation news release. 

Upon arrival, deputies encountered 42-year-old Charles Bradley Payne, who was initially armed with a baseball bat, according to the TBI.

Payne then dropped the bat and brandished a knife, which escalated the situation and resulted in one of the deputies firing his weapon, striking Payne, the TBI news release states.

Payne died at the scene.

No deputies sustained injuries in the incident.
A Hamilton County Sheriff's Office vehicle is seen at the scene of a shooting on the 9100 block of Broyles Drive on Tuesday, April 9, 2019 in Chattanooga, Tenn. A man is dead after an officer-involved shooting early Tuesday morning. Shortly after midnight, three Hamilton County deputies responded to a home in the 9100 block of Broyles Drive in East Brainerd on reports of a "disorderly subject," according to a Tennessee Bureau of Investigation news release. Upon arrival, deputies encountered 42-year-old Charles Bradley Payne, who was initially armed with a baseball bat, according to the TBI. Payne then dropped the bat and brandished a knife, which escalated the situation and resulted in one of the deputies firing his weapon, striking Payne, the TBI news release states. Payne died at the scene. No deputies sustained injuries in the incident.

The family of a man shot and killed in April by Hamilton County sheriff’s deputies has filed a wrongful death lawsuit and claims the county has refused to provide the names of the deputies involved in an attempt to let the statute of limitations lapse.

Charles Bradley Payne was killed on April 9 after deputies were called to a home in the 9100 block of Broyles Drive in East Brainerd on reports of a “disorderly subject,” the Times Free Press previously reported.

THE SHOOTING

The 42-year-old and his mother, Barbara Payne, were arguing when she asked him to leave her house, according to the lawsuit filed Thursday by attorney Robin Flores on behalf of Payne’s son, Justice Payne.

But Charles Payne didn’t want to leave, and according to the lawsuit his mother threatened to call police if he didn’t.