Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Woman accused of killing stranger for baby believes state employed jailhouse snitch

Catherine Goins
Catherine Goins

RINGGOLD, Ga. — Lawyers for a Catoosa County woman accused of killing a stranger to steal her baby say a spy approached the defendant in jail.

A court filing shows that the attorneys, Jerilyn Bell and Crystal Bice, believe Sasha Nichole Van Pelt asked Catherine Goins about her pending murder case while they were in jail together so that Van Pelt could give that information to the police or prosecutors.

During a pretrial hearing Tuesday, Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit District Attorney Herbert “Buzz” Franklin said he doesn’t know anything about such a plan. He said his investigator questioned Van Pelt last week about her time in jail with Goins, and Van Pelt denied working with any law enforcement employees.

photo Catherine Goins

The Catoosa County Sheriff’s Office charged Goins with murder in September. Sheriff Gary Sisk said Goins killed Natalia Roberts to steal Roberts’ baby.

Sisk said Goins’ boyfriend had just left her because he found out she lied to him about being pregnant. After Roberts died, Sisk said, Goins drove away with her 3 year old and 3 week old. She came back after calling a friend and telling him what happened.