Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Barrett: ‘Economic justice,’ and other clever ways to say ‘stealing’

The black heart of socialism is envy, and at the center of that heart is the wobbly conviction that stealing from the rich (aka anybody who has more than the socialist in question has) is not really stealing. It’s “economic justice.”

To sustain that conviction, it is necessary to dismiss the possibility that rich folks got that way through drive, skill, long working hours and such. If they are well off, it can only be because they robbed the poor, or cheated their employees, or came from loaded families. The proposition that they earned their wealth must be banished – not necessarily because of any real doubt that they earned it but because the thought that they might have come by their wealth legitimately risks making their critics feel bad about their own lack of initiative or ability.

It is more satisfying to assume rich people all got that way through luck or deceit rather than honest effort.

Such a conveniently all-encompassing explanation for unequal outcomes eliminates the need for pesky reflection. Indeed, it transforms government’s forcible seizure of the earnings of the rich (and of anybody whom government can convincingly label “rich”) into a righteous quest. It also opens wide the floodgates of preening self-adulation among those who believe that their rigorous decency toward their fellow man has kept them from the standard of living to which their obvious ethical superiority entitles them. If they can achieve that standard of living by cutting the malevolent, kitten-hating rich down to size through confiscatory taxes, so much the better.

Long ago in America, such behaviors and attitudes were called theft and covetousness, and were recognized as frailties to be conquered, mainly through prayer and God’s grace. Today, they are called “fairness” and “economic justice” – never to be confused with equal justice under the law – and they are celebrated as noble impulses to be cultivated.