BARRY: The puffy pink clouds that envelop the naked, though modestly covered, Katy Perry on the CD’s cover pretty much say it all: This album is cotton candy for fans of sugar-sweet pop music. I don’t dislike Perry or her music, and every now and then a catchy pop song can be fun, but you can’t survive on it. Too much of it, in fact, can be bad for you.
That’s where “Teenage Dream” suffers. The ubiquitous hit “California Gurls” is a decent song, especially with Snoop Dogg adding his flavor, and there are a couple of other good moments, but it gets tedious and old. Maybe a four-song EP would have been better.
CASEY: Absolutely. The album just screams of producers desperately adding second-rate songs to fill out the minutes between the obvious hits. That’s unfortunate, since it gives that much more credence to the argument that full album releases don’t make sense anymore (something I think Janelle Monáe’s “ArchAndroid” disproved).
When Perry attempts to shift away from her natural poppy element by being emo (“Circle the Drain”) or romantic (“Not Like the Movies,” “The One that Got Away”), she falls flat on her beautiful face. The worst offenders by far are “Fireworks” (which deserves the nickname “The Plastic Bag Song,” for its eye roll-inducing opening line) and “E.T.,” which goes nowhere, rather ironic for a song about a love that’s supposed to be out of this world.
BARRY: I actually didn’t dislike “Fireworks” as much as you did, but as I’ve said before, I listen more to melody than lyric much of the time. With that said, the sometimes explicit material alternates between being formulaic and over-produced and jarring, even for a woman who kissed a girl, and liked it. It seems clear the intent of this record is to produce hit singles.