Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: How to make school board culture wars worse

FRANKLIN, Tenn. – “What happens when a child sounds out the word ‘lesbian’ and turns to their teacher and asks, ‘What is a lesbian?'”

Trisha Lucente, the mom of a local kindergartner, has come before the Williamson County, Tenn., school board to voice her distress over the district’s continued use of Epic, a digital library app containing more than 40,000 children’s books and videos. Lucente and like-minded parents have complained about several titles that they consider inappropriate. Anything touching on race, gender or sexuality can set off alarms in conservative circles here.

In response, the school system temporarily shut down access to the library to conduct a review – prompting an outcry from supporters of the app – then reinstated it while allowing parents to opt out their kids.

Welcome to Williamson County, a hot spot in the ongoing culture war engulfing America’s public schools. An affluent, highly educated, politically conservative enclave just south of Nashville, Williamson has seen its share of school-related drama over the years. In 2015, for instance, conservatives here were fired up about a seventh grade social studies unit that some viewed as Islamic indoctrination.

Williamson County is obviously not the only community dealing with such frictions. School boards across the nation are being dragged onto the front lines of partisan battles. Vaccination requirements, diversity and inclusion efforts, books that make certain people feel icky – these issues and more have prompted ugly, overheated confrontations, some of them violent. Outside groups are fanning the flames, as are cynical politicians looking to juice their careers. (See: DeSantis, Ron, governor of Florida.) The day-to-day concerns of running a school district (boring stuff like budgeting and approving contracts for vendors) are increasingly being overshadowed by partisan agendas.