Skip to main content
Sunday, November 15, 2026Nov 15

Dionne: The party of Trump v. Merrick Garland

Merrick Garland, President Barack Obama's nominee to fill the Supreme Court vacancy, looks to Vice President Joe Biden as he is applauded during a Rose Garden news conference, at the White House in Washington Wednesday. Garland is currently chief judge for U.S. Court of Appeals D.C. Circuit. (Stephen Crowley/The New York Times)
Merrick Garland, President Barack Obama's nominee to fill the Supreme Court vacancy, looks to Vice President Joe Biden as he is applauded during a Rose Garden news conference, at the White House in Washington Wednesday. Garland is currently chief judge for U.S. Court of Appeals D.C. Circuit. (Stephen Crowley/The New York Times)

PHOENIX – In a span of about 12 hours, Americans were given definitive evidence that the Republican Party is now in thrall to its most ideologically and tactically extreme forces while the Democrats still look to the center ground and to compromise.

Exhibit A: The results of Tuesday’s primaries. Exhibit B: President Obama’s nomination of Judge Merrick Garland, as moderate and consensus-building a choice as he could have made, to the Supreme Court.

In the electoral showdowns, Donald Trump pulled off a near sweep. Yes, John Kasich, the most underrated candidate all year, managed to beat Trump in his home state of Ohio. But Trump defeated his opposition everywhere else and put a Jeb-like exclamation point on the day by trouncing Marco Rubio in his home state of Florida.

GOP establishmentarians had anointed Rubio as their savior, figuring the young and eloquent Cuban-American could cloak his very conservative positions under the appealing mantle of youth and diversity. It didn’t work.

Rubio learned that trying to be everyone’s backup choice rarely wins you first place. And members of an increasingly angry, old and overwhelmingly white Republican electorate have been told for seven years by their leaders (and sometimes by Rubio himself) that Obama is a radical trying to turn America into a foreign place. In large numbers, they heard what their party was saying and voted accordingly, for the candidate who most plainly echoes their extreme rage and alarm. Republican politicians are in no position to upbraid them now for how they are casting their ballots.