Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Victim in fatal Cleveland shooting was pulling suspect off his fiancee after he’d assaulted her before he was killed, authorities say

Matthew L. Wolfcale
Matthew L. Wolfcale
photo Matthew L. Wolfcale

A heated argument between a 25-year-old Cleveland, Tennessee man now charged with murder and his fiance led to Sunday’s fatal shooting at a Bates Pike Southeast home, a Bradley County Sheriff’s Office affidavit states.

Deputies who responded just after 4 a.m. Sunday to the residence found a white male laying face-down in the home’s driveway. The man, who gave his name as Matthew Wolfcale, was detained. He told a deputy at the time that, “I — up; I’m going to get so much time, but it was self defense,” the affidavit states.

Inside the home deputies discovered a white male, later identified as Jesse Johnson, laying face-down on a bathroom floor. When they rolled him over they realized he was deceased.

A woman inside the home, Ashley Wilson, told deputies she was Wolfcale’s fiance and that she and he have a one-year-old child. Wilson told deputies she and Wolfcale were in a heated argument in their bedroom and he had assaulted her and was on top of her.

When Johnson pulled Wolfcale off of Wilson, she told deputies, the two men struggled and she heard what the thought was a gunshot and left the room. She said she heard other shots, and that Wolfcale has a gun he keeps in the closet near where the two men were.