Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

State’s prime witness in fatal 2013 robbery recalls night of shooting

Carmisha Lay testifies before the jury is seated in the opening day of a murder trial for Stephen Lester on Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in Judge Tom Greenholtz's courtroom in Hamilton County Criminal Court in Chattanooga. Lester is facing charges in the January 2013 shooting death of Edward Glenn, Jr.
Carmisha Lay testifies before the jury is seated in the opening day of a murder trial for Stephen Lester on Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in Judge Tom Greenholtz's courtroom in Hamilton County Criminal Court in Chattanooga. Lester is facing charges in the January 2013 shooting death of Edward Glenn, Jr.
photo Stephen Lester enters Judge Tom Greenholtz’s courtroom on Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in Hamilton County Criminal Court in Chattanooga. Lester is facing multiple charges in the January 2013 shooting death of Edward Glenn, Jr.
photo Carmisha Shade Lay
photo Stephen Doantae Lester
photo Edward Lebron Glenn, Jr.

The state’s principal witness in the Hamilton County trial of a man accused of commanding his friend to fatally shoot a father of five during a robbery took the stand before jurors convened Wednesday morning.

Carmisha Lay, who pleaded guilty to second-degree murder earlier this week in exchange for witness testimony, told Judge Tom Greenholtz’s court that 27-year-old Stephen Lester, her then-boyfriend, arranged the robbery at 2500 O’Rear St. that resulted in Edward Glenn Jr.’s death.

Prosecutors said during Tuesday’s opening arguments that Lester, 27, told Lay and another friend to go “dance” for Glenn and his friends, with the end goal of robbing them, in January 2013.

Days later, between 3 a.m. and 4 a.m. on Jan. 10, Lay sent messages to Lester and another friend, Eric McReynolds, that Glenn was over at her home in her bed, prosecutors said.

When the men came to the house, Lester grabbed Lay by her neck and shoved her in the corner while McReynolds pistol-whipped Glenn, who was clothed only in a T-shirt and a sock, Lay testified. After they robbed Glenn, Lester commanded McReynolds to “shoot him, shoot him again,” Lay said.