NEW YORK — Clive Toye traveled to Jamaica and walked unannounced into the hotel where the Brazilian soccer club Santos was staying ahead of a friendly against the Reggae Boyz in January 1971. Pelé was sitting by the pool, and the New York Cosmos general manager began the cold call that changed United States sports history.
“You could go to Juventus, you could go to Real Madrid, yeah, you could win a championship. But so will other people,” the 90-year-old Toye recalled telling Pelé. “You come to us, you can win a country, and nobody else could do that except you.”
Dozens of meetings over four years led to Pelé agreeing to sign with the Cosmos of the North American Soccer League in June 1975. His 2 1/2 seasons in New York put U.S. soccer on a path to hosting the World Cup in 1994 and launching Major League Soccer two years later.
“There are probably two athletes that have transcended their sport and transcended sport overall in our lifetime,” MLS commissioner Don Garber said Thursday night after Pelé’s death at age 82. “One was Muhammad Ali, and the other was Pelé.”
The Cosmos averaged 3,578 fans in 1974 — a figure that nearly tripled to 10,450 the next year, with people lining the sides of the Triborough Bridge approach to watch games at Downing Stadium on Randalls Island.
