Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Tennessee lawmakers revisit 3rd grade retention law

Staff File Photo By Olivia Ross / A student in Kimberly Staton's third-grade class does classwork at Chattanooga School for the Liberal Arts on Jan. 13, 2023.
Staff File Photo By Olivia Ross / A student in Kimberly Staton's third-grade class does classwork at Chattanooga School for the Liberal Arts on Jan. 13, 2023.

Hand-wringing continues across the state as school administrators, teachers and parents consider what will happen if the state’s new third-grade reading retention law prevents thousands of students from moving on to fourth grade this year.

The law, passed in 2021, states that third-grade students who don’t score “on track” or “mastered” on standardized tests — and who don’t get help from summer “bridge” camps, tutors or re-testing — will repeat the third grade. Since 66% of the state’s students on last year’s test did not score “on track” or “mastered,” the number of grade repeaters stands to be substantial.

State Rep. John Ragan, R-Oak Ridge, is among many legislators who have proposed a combined 18 changes in the law. But the change he is proposing is not because he thinks the current law isn’t needed or won’t work.

Indeed, in a letter to a teacher who wrote to him and other legislators, he said this: “Reasonably considered, a proposal to neuter a newly enacted law prior to being able to observe its impacts is poor data-based decision-making. This is especially true since data exists on the situation without the law, i.e., a 66% grade-level literacy failure rate among Tennessee third-graders.”

The amendment to the reading law Ragan is proposing says that a third-grade student who is not proficient in English language arts (ELA) can be promoted to fourth grade if at least 66% of third-grade students in the student’s school district or public charter school test proficient on the ELA portion of the most recently administered Tennessee comprehensive assessment program test and if the student’s parent or guardian, teacher, and school principal mutually agree and recommend in writing that the student should be promoted to fourth grade.