Skip to main content
Friday, November 20, 2026Nov 20

Opinion: Lawmaker’s apology for ‘hanging by a tree’ comment falls short; it’s ‘better to remain silent’

Staff File Photo / The tombstone of 1906 lynching victim Ed Johnson lies in the Pleasant Gardens cemetery on the side of Missionary Ridge.
Staff File Photo / The tombstone of 1906 lynching victim Ed Johnson lies in the Pleasant Gardens cemetery on the side of Missionary Ridge.

The late, conservative radio talk show host Rush Limbaugh used to frequently invoke the term “words mean things” when he cited hypocritical, hyperbolic or hysterical comments from politicians.

His point was that politicians — he was usually talking about Democrats, of course — who made the comments to get attention, make a point or skewer an opponent often later said they didn’t really mean what they said.

But words, Limbaugh insisted, have meaning.

The closer we’ve observed politics through the years, the more we believe he was right. Politicians may play down their remarks, but their previous and subsequent actions indicate they meant they said.

So it is that we have a hard time accepting the apology from Tennessee state Rep. Paul Sherrell, R-Sparta, who suggested during a House Criminal Justice Committee meeting Tuesday that the state consider adding “hanging by a tree” as a method of capital punishment.