The Supreme Court may be beginning its summer recess, but the furor over the justices’ ethical lapses is still gathering steam. We now know that both Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito have gone on lavish vacations with court litigants without disclosing the trips or recusing themselves from their benefactors’ cases. Thomas has also accepted extravagant gifts. Congress should pass new ethics rules for the justices before they reconvene on the first Monday of October
Though the developing reform effort appears fairly modest — Senate Judiciary Chairman Dick Durbin said last week he’s focused on “a code of ethics, increased disclosure requirements and clear rules dictating when justices must recuse themselves from cases” — the action to date is single-party.
What might be worse: Some court-watchers are insisting Thomas and Alito did nothing wrong in accepting their largesse. That’s a preposterous position considering the legal standard for bias, as summarized three decades ago by Justice John Paul Stevens: “The relevant inquiry […] is not whether or not the judge was actually biased but whether he or she appeared biased.”
It’s worth noting every justice currently on the court could be accused of some ethical failure.
Chief Justice John Roberts has failed to recuse himself in a handful of petitions despite having a financial stake in a party. Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Neil Gorsuch have failed to recuse themselves in petitions in which their book publisher was a party. Justice Elena Kagan never recused herself in any major Obamacare case, though her office crafted the law’s legal defense when she was U.S. solicitor general. Justice Brett Kavanaugh met with the head of an anti-LGBT group just after the group filed amicus briefs in two cases. Justice Amy Coney Barrett said the justices were not “a bunch of partisan hacks” at the University of Louisville’s (Mitch) McConnell Center — standing four feet from Sen. McConnell, who was majority leader when she was confirmed. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson omitted multiple free, reportable trips from her disclosures.
