With the end of the Supreme Court’s 2022 term, what have we learned about the most junior justice? To some, Ketanji Brown Jackson has been a reliable vote for the liberal coalition; others contend that she’s a swing vote with a tendency to surprise her fans by joining the court’s conservatives.
In truth, one year is too short a time to reach a reliable conclusion; the sample size is too small. Still, on the evidence so far, I’m struck by a quite different thought — that she might prove a worthy successor to the first Justice Jackson. That would be Robert H., the Nuremberg prosecutor, perhaps the most influential member of the court in the middle years of the 20th century, who was lauded in particular for his close and careful reading of statutes. That fascination with the details of the law might be the most overlooked aspect of her first term.
Just consider how Jackson writes. She has mostly resisted the habit, unhappily common on the current court, of penning opinions with an apparent eye to quotation in the press. Instead, she writes … well, like a lawyer: “It soon became clear that our primary and secondary escheatment rules were resulting in inequitable distributions, at least with respect to particular instruments.” Try posting that on social media and see how often it’s retweeted.
I applaud Jackson’s recognition of why judges write opinions at all. The Supreme Court is a court of law, and the principal audience for its opinions is, properly, the bar. Activists might wax furious or dance with delight over the outcome of a given case, but for the lawyer or the legal scholar, the first question should involve not the result but the quality of the reasoning. And that’s where, just like her namesake, Jackson shines. Particularly when a case turns on the close and careful reading of a statute, she crafts meticulous opinions.
Yes, Jackson sometimes votes differently from the rest of the liberal bloc, but those occasions, too, tend to reflect her insistence on precision in understanding the words with which Congress expresses itself.
