Since 2019 when COVID-19 emerged in China, scientists worldwide have been trying to ascertain the origin of the virus.
The two major theories are a natural spillover from bats to an animal source and then to humans or a laboratory accident. A related question is whether the virus emerged from nature or was the result of human-made genetic manipulation.
Until recently, although no animal intermediary between virus-carrying bats and humans has been identified, Chinese scientists and many of their Western counterparts, including prominent American researchers, argued that animals transmitted the virus to humans. They downplayed the lab leak theory and essentially dismissed the possibility that the virus was engineered rather than a creation of nature.
Particularly notable was a report on the pandemic’s origin released in March 2021 by the World Health Organization, which failed to identify the source of the virus but claimed an animal source was “likely to very likely.” Only a few pages of the report and its annexes addressed the possibility of a laboratory accident, and a lab leak was deemed so unlikely that the virus having been carried into China on frozen food packages was posed as a more probable explanation.
This scenario strained credulity but was a convenient way of shifting the blame away from China, which had a say in determining which facts outsiders could investigate. Not incidentally, the natural-origin theory also protected Chinese scientists and their foreign sources of funding from inconvenient questions about safety protocols and the wisdom or foolishness of dangerous research projects.
