Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Sorry, kids, the courts won’t save the planet

File photo/Janie Osborne/The New York Times / Youth plaintiffs in Held v. State of Montana gather at Pioneer Park in Helena, Mont., on June 13, 2023. A judge in Montana ruled on Monday, Aug. 14, 2023, that young people in the state have a constitutional right to a healthful environment, finding in a landmark case that the states failure to consider climate change when evaluating new projects was causing harm.
File photo/Janie Osborne/The New York Times / Youth plaintiffs in Held v. State of Montana gather at Pioneer Park in Helena, Mont., on June 13, 2023. A judge in Montana ruled on Monday, Aug. 14, 2023, that young people in the state have a constitutional right to a healthful environment, finding in a landmark case that the states failure to consider climate change when evaluating new projects was causing harm.

The decision sounds monumental: A Montana court has ruled that climate change is real and caused by humans and that governments owe their constituents’ children a clean environment. Surely this will eradicate the last traces of America’s climate denialism and accelerate the transition to a green-energy future.

Except … no. The Montana decision may sound as big as the local sky, but its practical implications are far narrower. It’s a win for climate activists, but a small one. Mainly, it’s a reminder that the global climate emergency is too complex for any one solution. Few, if any, will be crafted in courtrooms.

The Montana case arose from decrees by the state’s conservative legislature that government agencies must ignore climate change when making decisions, such as approving fossil-fuel exploration or new energy plants. This conveniently greased the skids for a new natural-gas plant to be built on the Yellowstone River over the objections of environmentalists and local residents.

A few years ago, representatives for a bunch of kids, today ranging in age from 5 to 22, sued the state over this. They argued that the refusal to consider the climate impacts of Montana’s fossil fuel-based economy violated the state’s constitution, which guarantees “a clean and healthful environment in Montana for present and future generations.”

This week, a judge ruled the kids were right. Environmentalists rejoiced.