Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: The House Republicans’ shutdown politics are dumb and dumber

Photo/Kenny Holston/The New York Times / House Speaker Kevin McCarthy speaks to reporters at the U.S. Capitol building as budget negotiations are ongoing at the Capitol in Washington on Sept. 22, 2023. Right-wing Republicans who represent a minority in their party and in Congress have succeeded in sowing mass dysfunction.
Photo/Kenny Holston/The New York Times / House Speaker Kevin McCarthy speaks to reporters at the U.S. Capitol building as budget negotiations are ongoing at the Capitol in Washington on Sept. 22, 2023. Right-wing Republicans who represent a minority in their party and in Congress have succeeded in sowing mass dysfunction.

For years, I stalked the Capitol halls amid Congress’ fiscal-year-end follies, waiting with other reporters for a breakthrough to end the latest faux crisis. I’m hard-pressed to recall a budget fight so politically self-defeating as the one now cleaving the House — waged for stupid reasons by stupid people.

And lest that sound too harsh, I defer to New York Rep. Mike Lawler, speaking to reporters about his fellow Republicans who’ve provoked the current chaos: “This is stupidity,” Lawler said. “It’s a clown show,” he added, the inevitable result of “running lunatics” for Congress.

Yup, the lunatics are fully in charge of Kevin McCarthy’s asylum, a.k.a. the House of Representatives. Speaker McCarthy most definitely is not in control, so Congress is careening toward an almost-certain government shutdown at the end of next week. He’s in a box, in fact, with no way out that doesn’t risk his being cashiered as speaker in a right-wing putsch.

Even if he survives, McCarthy could well forfeit the speakership after the 2024 elections: House Republicans’ MAGA mayhem and extremism threaten to cost them the thin majority they won only last year.

You’d think they’d learn from the example of Senate Republicans, who’ve provided a contrast of pragmatism and relative moderation. The same political analysts now downgrading House Republicans’ election chances have Senate Republicans favored to move from a minority to the majority in ’24.