Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge rules Tennessee Jewish couple, denied service by state-funded foster home, may proceed with lawsuit

Contributed photo / Knox County couple Elizabeth and Gabriel Rutan-Ram allege a publicly funded Christian child-placement agency refused to serve them because they are Jewish — and that a new Tennessee law permitting the policy violates their constitutional rights.
Contributed photo / Knox County couple Elizabeth and Gabriel Rutan-Ram allege a publicly funded Christian child-placement agency refused to serve them because they are Jewish — and that a new Tennessee law permitting the policy violates their constitutional rights.

A Tennessee appellate judge ruled that a Knox County couple may proceed with a lawsuit alleging a state-funded foster care agency denied them services because they are Jewish.

A lower court had previously ruled the couple lacked standing to sue in the case, in which dueling visions of religious liberty face off.

The couple, Elizabeth and Gabriel Rutan-Ram, are challenging a Tennessee law stating that faith-based foster and adoption-placement institutions can, on the basis of a religious objection, deny service to potential clients — and could not lose access to public funds as a result.

In court, the couple and several taxpayer plaintiffs argued the law sanctions unconstitutional religious discrimination.