Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: The New York Times has an edge in suit against OpenAI

File photo/Sasha Maslov/The New York Times / The New York Times, whose headquarters in Manhattan is shown on May 12, 2021, sued OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement on Wednesday, Dec. 27, 2023, opening a new front in the increasingly intense legal battle over the unauthorized use of published work to train artificial intelligence technologies.
File photo/Sasha Maslov/The New York Times / The New York Times, whose headquarters in Manhattan is shown on May 12, 2021, sued OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement on Wednesday, Dec. 27, 2023, opening a new front in the increasingly intense legal battle over the unauthorized use of published work to train artificial intelligence technologies.

The lawsuit filed by The New York Times against OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement pits one of the great establishment media institutions against the purveyor of a transformative new technology. Symbolically, the case promises a clash of the titans: labor-intensive human newsgathering against pushbutton information produced by artificial intelligence. But legally, the case represents something different: a classic instance of the lag between established law and emerging technology.

Copyright law, a set of rules that date back to the printing press, was not designed to cover large language models (LLM) like ChatGPT.

The key legal issue in the case will be the doctrine known as fair use. Codified in the Copyright Act of 1976, fair use tells you when it’s acceptable to use text copyrighted by someone else.

The Times will point to examples where a user asks a question of ChatGPT or Bing and it replies with something substantially like a New York Times article. The newspaper will observe that ChatGPT is part of a business and charges fees for access to its latest versions, and that Bing is a core part of Microsoft’s business. The Times will emphasize the creative aspects of journalism. Above all, it will argue that if you can ask an LLM-powered search engine for the day’s news, and get content drawn directly from the New York Times, that will substantially harm and maybe even kill the Times’ business model.

Most of these points are plausible legal arguments. But OpenAI and Microsoft will be prepared for them. They’ll likely respond by saying that their LLM doesn’t copy; rather, it learns and makes statistical predictions to produce new answers. If I read an article in the New York Times and then write a Bloomberg opinion column on the same topic, that isn’t copyright infringement, even though I may have learned a great deal from the Times piece and relied on that information to form my own opinion.