It’s funny how we all talk about “comfort food” as if it’s a simple, clearly defined thing. From time to time, we even see stories about an “ultimate” comfort food: Think mashed potatoes. But the reality is that the concept is among the most complicated and ill-defined in all of cooking, mainly because it’s completely subjective. We all have our own food memories that translate to comfort.
There are people for whom mashed potatoes would not be a comfort at all, never mind an “ultimate” one.
(READ MORE: Kennedy: Quarter Pounders are comfort food)
Likewise, there are undoubtedly a lot of people for whom a casserole of any kind would not appeal. I think I finally convinced my husband that casserole can be a good thing, but it took a few years since he grew up on meat and potatoes.
For me and a lot of children of the mid-20th century, a bubbling, golden-crusted, fresh-from-the oven casserole is one of the most comforting things imaginable. It rarely matters what’s in it as long as it’s piping hot and full of whatever familiar flavors and textures make us feel safe and loved.