Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: On bump stocks, the Supreme Court is divorced from reality

File photo/Erin Schaff/The New York Times / An AR-15 style firearm is displayed at Clark Brothers Gun Shop in Warrenton, Virginia, on Feb. 25, 2018. The Supreme Court heard
oral arguments about a bump stock ban, a Trump administration rule put in place after the Las Vegas massacre.
File photo/Erin Schaff/The New York Times / An AR-15 style firearm is displayed at Clark Brothers Gun Shop in Warrenton, Virginia, on Feb. 25, 2018. The Supreme Court heard oral arguments about a bump stock ban, a Trump administration rule put in place after the Las Vegas massacre.

Every so often, a Supreme Court oral argument is so divorced from reality that even a seasoned court-watcher like myself finds it jaw-dropping. The court’s consideration of whether the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives was right to define guns equipped with bump stocks as machine guns was exactly that shocking.

The justices spent almost the entire time debating the technical workings of bump stocks and the meaning of the words “function” and “trigger” in the federal law that bans machine guns. No one, justice or lawyer, bothered to mention the real-world consequence of permitting bump stocks: They let mass shooters turn their semiautomatic assault rifles into effectively automatic weapons that fire up to 800 rounds a minute.

The whole sorry spectacle reminded me of the long-running debate about whether to allow television cameras into the Supreme Court to cover oral argument. Court insiders have long commented wryly that, if the cameras were allowed, the public would soon discover just how technical, dry and boring oral arguments really are.

But if the public had bothered to tune in to watch the bump stock argument, they might have done more than change the channel. They might have stormed the court in outrage that the justices seemed unable to address the real reason the ATF under then-President Donald Trump redefined bump stocks as machine guns after the Las Vegas mass shooting in October 2017.

You might think the culprit in the Supreme Court’s failed oral argument is just lawyers being lawyers.