Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Tennessee’s Education Freedom Scholarship Act: No accountability, no bill

Staff File Photo By Matt Hamilton / Esmeralda Rivera, a third grade teacher at Ooltewah Elementary School, puts up a poster Aug. 4, 2022, to help students communicate their feelings in her classroom.
Staff File Photo By Matt Hamilton / Esmeralda Rivera, a third grade teacher at Ooltewah Elementary School, puts up a poster Aug. 4, 2022, to help students communicate their feelings in her classroom.

When it comes to legislation that does or does not pass the Tennessee General Assembly, it’s a long way to “sine die,” the expression that annually ends the session.

But we have very grave misgivings about at least one pillar contained in an inadvertently filed state Senate bill on Gov. Bill Lee’s Education Freedom Scholarship Act.

The draft bill filed Monday due to a miscommunication and later removed has no accountability measures — or mention of the word accountability — for students who would receive a scholarship and move from a public to a nonpublic school. In other words, if nothing is changed when the actual bill is filed, or through amendments along the way, no accountability requirements would measure whether students are faring better in their nonpublic school than they did in public schools.

The state’s current Education Savings Account Program, available to qualified students in Davidson, Hamilton and Shelby counties, requires students to take the annual Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP) tests in English language arts and math.

Our hope for that pilot program was that it would measure student scores for at least five years before legislators sought any broad expansion. That way, it would be clear whether the scholarships were making a positive change, making no difference or making things worse.