We are living in the age of moral panic. We look around, we see a problem, and we rush to outlaw something. Ban TikTok! cry members of Congress. Ban social media for kids! says the state of Florida. Ban immigrants, ban hate speech, ban imports, ban union shops.
Part of what makes a moral panic a moral panic is that fear overwhelms any effort at moderation. Politicians follow the panic. And throughout the nation’s history, an awful lot of moral panics have involved foreigners. Today’s cases in point: The right’s view on immigration and the left’s on Russian election interference.
Back in the 1960s, the economist George Stigler famously wrote that passing a law does not solve a problem. He was arguing against government tendency to impose regulation without sufficient evidence — a process, wrote the future Nobel laureate, that tends to result in rules that are “capricious and arbitrary in high degree.”
In the proposed TikTok ban, we see both aspects of the problem: a lack of evidence and an arbitrary result. But that’s nothing new. Laws resulting from moral panics generally fit that model. And, once adopted, they’re tough to get off the books.
Consider a few examples.
