Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorney of Hamilton County man accused of second-degree murder wants evidence tossed because rights were not read

Staff photo / A person exits the Courts Building in 2016 in Chattanooga. An attorney's motion to suppress evidence in the case of Andrew Smith, who is charged with second-degree murder, was heard Thursday in front of Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn.
Staff photo / A person exits the Courts Building in 2016 in Chattanooga. An attorney's motion to suppress evidence in the case of Andrew Smith, who is charged with second-degree murder, was heard Thursday in front of Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn.


A Hamilton County attorney said evidence in Andrew Smith’s second-degree murder case should be dismissed because Collegedale police did not read Smith his rights to an attorney and to refuse to answer questions.

Smith is accused of giving fentanyl to his fiancee, Angela Whitt, last year, which led to her overdose death in their apartment.

Steven Brown, the defendant’s attorney, filed a motion last year to suppress the statements Smith made to law enforcement and the consent he gave authorities to search his cellphone. On Thursday, Brown and Chief Opioid Prosecutor Jamie Pulido argued their respective points in front of Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn.

On April 16, 2023, Smith contacted police to report Whitt’s death after he allegedly tampered with evidence, Collegedale police Detective Robert O’Daniel testified.