Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Trump judge followed radical Supreme Court’s playbook

Photo/U.S. Department of Justice via The New York Times / A photo provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and released on June 9, 2023, shows boxes of documents stored in a bathroom at Mar-a-Lago, former President Donald Trump's private club and residence in Palm Beach, Fla. Judge Aileen Cannon on Monday, July 15, 2024, dismissed in its entirety the classified documents case against Trump, ruling that the appointment of the special counsel, Jack Smith, had violated the Constitution.
Photo/U.S. Department of Justice via The New York Times / A photo provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and released on June 9, 2023, shows boxes of documents stored in a bathroom at Mar-a-Lago, former President Donald Trump's private club and residence in Palm Beach, Fla. Judge Aileen Cannon on Monday, July 15, 2024, dismissed in its entirety the classified documents case against Trump, ruling that the appointment of the special counsel, Jack Smith, had violated the Constitution.

You don’t need a legal expert to tell you that Judge Aileen Cannon’s decision striking down the appointment of Jack Smith as special counsel to investigate former President Donald Trump is terribly wrong. What’s less obvious is that Cannon’s opinion isn’t just the work of a far-right wingnut. Rather, Cannon’s decision is a second-rate pastiche of the kinds of decisions the conservative Supreme Court has been issuing as part of its constitutional revolution.

Put another way, Cannon isn’t a loose cannon. She’s a soldier in a much bigger legal battle to rewrite constitutional law being led by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. The conservative legal movement, exemplified by the Federalist Society, has long made it a priority to appoint conservative judges to as many judicial posts as possible, and they’ve done so in partnership with Republican presidents like Trump and Senate leaders like Mitch McConnell. This gave Trump a large number of appointments during just one term in office — Cannon among them.

To see how Cannon’s opinion followed a script written at the Supreme Court, consider its most outrageous element: It directly contradicts explicit Supreme Court precedent that goes back to the Nixon v. U.S. decision from 1974. That precedent is famous. Decided unanimously by the Supreme Court, it held that Nixon couldn’t hide behind executive privilege to withhold the Watergate tapes from special prosecutor Leon Jaworski. It’s no exaggeration to say that this was the decision that led to Nixon’s resignation.

Nor is there any doubt about what the Supreme Court said in the case. Reciting the same statutes that underlie the current special counsel regulations, the justices said that “Congress has vested in the Attorney General the power to … appoint subordinate officers to assist him in [criminal litigation]” and that “the Attorney General has delegated the authority” “to a Special Prosecutor” pursuant to regulations. Then the unequivocal punchline: “So long as this regulation is extant, it has the force of law.”

So how, you may well ask, could a lowly district court judge announce that these sentences — written by the Supreme Court in one of its most prominent cases — are constitutionally wrong? Cue the current conservative constitutional revolution, which is all about overturning 50-year-old precedents. In his concurrence in the recent Trump immunity case, Thomas questioned the U.S. v. Nixon precedent for giving only “passing reference” to the relevant statutes and failing to analyze their text. Cannon took this as a signal to treat the precedent as passé.