Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Trump isn’t going to like the Supreme Court’s immunity decision

Photo/Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times / The Supreme Court is seen in Washington on Monday, July 1, 2024. Justices declared on Monday that former presidents have immunity for their official actions, upending the case against Donald Trump over his attempts to subvert his 2020 election loss.
Photo/Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times / The Supreme Court is seen in Washington on Monday, July 1, 2024. Justices declared on Monday that former presidents have immunity for their official actions, upending the case against Donald Trump over his attempts to subvert his 2020 election loss.

Anyone who expected the Supreme Court to give clear guidance on the extent to which former President Donald Trump can be tried (and tried and tried) for the crimes of which he has been accused must surely be disappointed with the complexity of what the justices decided in Trump v. United States. The case was sent back to the lower courts for further proceedings.

But clarity shouldn’t have been expected, not least because there are, essentially, no precedents.

There’s much in Chief Justice John Roberts’s majority opinion to hearten the former president — part of the indictment brought by Special Counsel Jack Smith will be dismissed. But the prosecution, too, gets an important a piece of what it wanted.

And although the decision is being reported as a big win for Trump, I’m not sure that’s so.

To begin with, the court rightly rejected Trump’s absurd position that a former president can’t be prosecuted for his conduct in office unless he has been impeached and removed. The court also rightly rejected the absurd position of the special counsel that the president enjoys no immunity at all.