Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

This is the secret to the perfect baked potato

A feast of baked potatoes, with assorted toppings. From left: Hot Honey Baked Sweet Potatoes, Caramelized Kimchi Baked Potatoes and Aglio e Olio Baked Potatoes. /  Christopher Testani/The New York Times
A feast of baked potatoes, with assorted toppings. From left: Hot Honey Baked Sweet Potatoes, Caramelized Kimchi Baked Potatoes and Aglio e Olio Baked Potatoes. / Christopher Testani/The New York Times

Turns out, the baked potato has always been big and great.

In 1909, Hazen Titus, the dining-car superintendent on the Northern Pacific Railway, had a vision: Having learned of a surplus of oversize spuds, he’d ordered them up and placed them on his menu. His “Great Big Baked Potato” became a hit, to be ordered, appropriately, on a train route of the same name.

These days, a long Idaho tuber, split down the middle like a hot dog bun to reveal fluffy white starch, a pat of butter nestled into the left side, is still big and – more important – great, with its perfect creamy-crunchy-fresh combo of sour cream, chives, cheese and bacon.

I spent the past year baking pounds and pounds of potatoes to come to a simple conclusion: The baked potato is worth celebration. There may be no better (and easier) way to gather than by building on a reliable but never boring base and delighting in each turn of the flavor wheel.

Here are my tips for success.