Recently, a bungled health warning over black plastic spatulas didn’t help faltering trust in science. First, researchers warned us to throw away the ubiquitous utensils because the recycling process might have incorporated toxic contaminants beyond the Environmental Protection Agency’s safety limits. Then someone pointed out the researchers had made a big math error. The black plastic warning turned out to have been based on incorrect information. Contaminant levels were actually more than 10 times lower than EPA limits.
It wouldn’t surprise me if Americans remained wary of black plastic utensils. Alarming health news, especially when it comes from prestigious universities or other trusted sources, has a way of lodging in people’s minds. Corrective information, such as reports pointing out the math fumble in the black spatula study, has less shock value and tends to get lost in the torrent of news around the initial scare.
The great proliferation of black plastic spatulas itself was spawned by a spate of health scares of varying credibility. Experts had warned that it was dangerous to use a metal spatula because it could scratch nonstick cookware, allowing plastic and “forever chemicals” into food. Before that, we bought the chemically coated pans because of a scare over fat, which for centuries had kept food from sticking to cookware.
Scientists inevitably are going to make mistakes, but in this case and others like it, they stuck by their conclusion that the products they studied had high risk potential even as they corrected their math.
Sometimes researchers might gloss over problems with their findings as long as they feel that the overall message will lead to good outcomes for society. And it probably isn’t the end of the world to lose all those plastic spatulas. But often there are unintended consequences.
