Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Review: A writerly love story, happy ending not guaranteed

Photo by Leah Holt / Katie Holt
Photo by Leah Holt / Katie Holt

“NOT IN MY BOOK” by Katie Holt (Alcove Press, 320 pages, $20).

The debut romance novel from Tennessee writer Katie Holt, “Not in My Book,” is a steamy slow burn in which the two main characters write a romance novel together. It can be a risky venture to write a novel about writing a novel, but this one is delightful. After many hilarious stops and starts, the couple ignite their own unexpected love story and must figure out how their book — and their story — will end.

Rosie is a plucky Peruvian American who leaves her small town in Tennessee to pursue an MFA in creative writing in New York City. She’s a hard-working student determined to make it as a writer while simultaneously convincing her fellow students and professors to take romance seriously. Rosie’s love of the genre was passed down from her immigrant mother who read every Harlequin she could get her hands on. When Rosie’s mother discovers her daughter with her stack of books, she takes a Sharpie to the raunchy sex scenes but it’s only a matter of time before Rosie can buy her own romance novels.

When Rosie is asked by a classmate to defend her preference for the oft-dismissed literary genre, she replies, “I had grown up determined to be a novelist. I’d decided I had to publish romance novels and make hopeless romantics around the world swoon — there was nothing else for me out there. Romance had shaped my worldview, molding how I lived with optimism and hope.” That inquiring classmate is Aiden Huntington, a good-looking literary fiction writer who becomes Rosie’s nemesis and, eventually, her writing partner.

Rosie has a crush on Aiden until the two meet in a novel-writing class. After weeks of Aiden’s biting critiques — he’s not a fan of romance — and Rosie’s truculent replies in workshop, their professor loses her patience and gives the two an ultimatum: To stay in the class, they must write a romance novel together. What ensues is a slightly predictable enemies-to-lovers story that is redeemed by its delightful and witty storytelling.