Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Trade trouble: Let free trade work its magic

Photo/Matt Rourke/The Associated Press / Bottles of Canadian whisky line the shelves at a Pennsylvania Fine Wine & Good Spirits in Flourtown, Pa., on Thursday, March 13, 2025.
Photo/Matt Rourke/The Associated Press / Bottles of Canadian whisky line the shelves at a Pennsylvania Fine Wine & Good Spirits in Flourtown, Pa., on Thursday, March 13, 2025.

Tariff advocates have three main arguments. One, they raise revenue. Two, they revive domestic industries. And three, they are a diplomatic negotiating tool. Not only do these arguments not stand on their own, they contradict one another.

It’s true, the government consumes lots of money. Currently, its primary source of revenue other than debt is the income tax, which is projected to bring in about $2.5 trillion this year. An additional $1.7 trillion will come from payroll taxes, again garnered from your paycheck. Could tariffs replace this?

The simple answer is no. President Donald Trump has already announced tariffs on our primary trading partners, Canada and Mexico. (For all the hyperbole surrounding it, our trade with China accounts for a much smaller amount of imports.)

The estimated revenue from those tariffs amounts to a comparatively measly $110 billion this year, including the tiny revenue effects of ending the “de minimis” exemptions that allow consumers to order small items affordably from abroad.

There isn’t enough trade to make up the gap between tariff revenue and income taxes to allow for tariffs to become the primary source of revenue in modern times. When tariffs were last the primary source of government funding, in the Gilded Age (called that to give the impression of riches without real substance), the federal government was tiny, with even military spending being minimal by today’s standards.