A disturbing feature of America’s current foreign policy is its new transactional nature, imposed by our most recent president, a real estate investor who enjoyed varying degrees of success in business before entering politics. The question arises: Can you engage in world politics the way you might manage a New York real estate firm? We, and the rest of the world, are finding out.
People go into real estate to make money. Not to make people happy, or to perform a civic duty or a public service. Their success in business is defined by whether, at the end of the day, they turn a profit. When this mindset is applied to politics and diplomacy, things can go akilter, as they have recently. Our international exchanges have been recast with new terms, new formalities.
We no longer negotiate: we make deals. Our erstwhile trading partners have become opponents. A peace settlement is a game. We don’t have a position or talking points, we hold cards. Ours are good. Their cards are bad, when they have any. Countries with whom we have worked peacefully for decades are now being told that they have not been spending enough on overhead, or that they would be better off if we annexed them. We are threatening to leave the game and go elsewhere (but to where?), all the while neglecting to consider where the game has been and continues to be played.
Can we afford to treat so casually NATO, an alliance formed in the aftermath of the most expensive real estate deal ever? World War II was fought at enormous cost, and it is easy to forget all these years later that many countries paid far more than others and in ways that defy calculation. Can we reduce to monetary terms the costs and benefits of the NATO alliance without distorting its value — what that alliance has meant and continues to mean to the peace and security of democratic nations around the world?
The tariffs, we have been told, are a beautiful thing, and they are going to make us rich. In adopting this strategy, Trump is assuming that both his MAGA people and the rest of America want the same thing: to be rich. We’re going to be so wealthy, he has regularly reminded us, when he has his way and his deals go through, as if most people want what successful realtors want. But what if his assumption is incorrect or overly simplistic? What if most Americans want what George Bailey might have called “four walls and a chimney” and the life that image suggests: a safe and happy home to return to after a good day’s work?
