Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Who invented the March Madness bracket? Staten Island bar and Kentucky postal worker stake claims

Terence Haggerty talks to customers in his family bar, Jody's Club Forest, in Staten Island, New York, Monday, March 10, 2025. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
Terence Haggerty talks to customers in his family bar, Jody's Club Forest, in Staten Island, New York, Monday, March 10, 2025. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)


NEW YORK (AP) — Could it really be true? That of all of college basketball’s urban myths, one of New York’s five boroughs is actually the birthplace of filling out an NCAA Tournament bracket?

Before all those office pools truly defined March, betting the bracket was the supposed brainchild of an Irish pub owner in Staten Island — a “creative businessman,” his son calls him — whose straightforward idea of plunking down 10 bucks to pick the Final Four teams and the national champion turned the unassuming spot into a bustling attraction where the special of the day could be a million-dollar payout.

“We created a pool that just blew up over time,” current bar owner Terence Haggerty said. “Looking back at it now, how did we pull it off? How did we do it? It was crazy.”

Through the decades of Larry and Magic, of Jordan and Laettner, through word of mouth and an embarrassment of riches, the contest took off — so much so that the West Brighton neighborhood favorite, Jody’s Club Forest, stakes its claim (though not without at least one other contender to the crown) as the bar that helped ignite the bracket into a billion-dollar business.