Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Blackwell: For Christians, the cost of certainty over faith

L.B. Blackwell
L.B. Blackwell

More than a decade ago, when my wife and I still imagined we would be a churchgoing family, we visited a well-known congregation in Chattanooga. We had heard some great music there and wanted to see whether it might be a good fit for us. Before the main service, we attended a Sunday School class, part of which involved a conversation between my wife and one or two church elders. The only thing I remember clearly from that conversation is a question one of the elders asked us. I mean, I am pretty sure he asked both me and my wife the same question, but all I remember is wrestling with how I would answer it. The question was: Are you absolutely sure you are saved and will go to heaven after you die?

Even then, at a time in my life when calling myself a Christian was as simple as calling myself a Tennessean and the thought of leaving the evangelical denomination of my childhood for a (still conservative) mainline church felt deliciously rebellious, I couldn’t give the elder a straight answer. I don’t remember what I actually said, but it was likely hedged with qualifiers. Either way, it’s the question itself that I want to consider.

Somehow, for many Christians (and likely members of other religious traditions), certainty has come to be mistaken for faith. Here in the buckle of the Bible Belt, you can’t travel far without passing a billboard offering truth at the other end of a toll-free number. Folks will even come to your front door and happily give you the address to the pearly gates. Or just grab one of those free pamphlets that explains the formula for eternal life in a few easy steps.

I don’t deny the good intentions behind these efforts to share one’s faith with others. No doubt many of the people who take the time to support such efforts have had powerful, life-changing religious experiences and feel impelled to pass on their good news. Nor do I fault the understandable desire for certainty among humans of all religious stripes (or none). To be certain of something brings comfort and a sense of control, since what is certain is fixed, settled and unchanging. It’s nailed down, as we say. Uncertainty, on the other hand, is literally unsettling.

Nevertheless, there are serious problems with our attempts at certainty. Contemporary psychiatrist and philosopher Iain McGilchrist, in his book “The Master and His Emissary”, writes that “[c]ertainty is … related to narrowness, as though the more certain we become of something the less we see.” Using the human eye to illustrate this point, he explains that the part of the eye that has the clearest focus (the fovea) perceives a field of vision just one degree across. The cost of certainty, McGilchrist seems to suggest, is near-total blindness. We can’t see what we don’t notice.