Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act challenges role of the courts

File photo/Ariana Cubillos/The Associated Press / Jasmin Ramirez holds a photo of her son, Angelo Escalona, at a government-organized rally protesting the deportation of alleged members of the Venezuelan Tren de Aragua gang, who were transferred to an El Salvador prison, in Caracas, Venezuela, Tuesday, March 18, 2025. Ramirez said she hadn't heard from her son since he called to say he was with a group of migrants about to be deported on March 14.
File photo/Ariana Cubillos/The Associated Press / Jasmin Ramirez holds a photo of her son, Angelo Escalona, at a government-organized rally protesting the deportation of alleged members of the Venezuelan Tren de Aragua gang, who were transferred to an El Salvador prison, in Caracas, Venezuela, Tuesday, March 18, 2025. Ramirez said she hadn't heard from her son since he called to say he was with a group of migrants about to be deported on March 14.

The fight in Federal Judge James Boasberg’s D.C. courtroom over whether President Donald Trump can use the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to summarily fly Venezuelan immigrants to a Salvadoran mega-prison without trial or charge is a fight over the strength of our constitutional system.

It would be a mistake to think about this case as just about immigration. The arguments that government attorneys have been advancing before Boasberg are not only geared towards preserving their ability to continue these removals — based on unseen evidence under a misused wartime authority — but indeed take direct aim at judicial powers.

You can boil a lot of what Trump is pushing here to a simple argument: We’re at war with Venezuelan street gangs so the president can use wartime powers that ride roughshod over the courts and our constitutional protections. But this isn’t a war. We’ve fought wars with England and Germany, with Japan and North Vietnam. America knows what war looks like.

What’s next? At war with liberals, with Democrats, with the press?

Even conservative Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts has had enough, scolding Trump who called for impeaching Boasberg.