Of the endless torrent of illegal, unconstitutional — and anti-constitutional — actions flowing from the Trump administration, there are three that stand out for their contempt for the rule of law.
There is President Donald Trump’s ongoing assault on the right to due process, seen in his administration’s refusal to facilitate the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the Maryland man who was arrested in Baltimore in March and removed to a prison in El Salvador. Not only is the White House ignoring an order from the Supreme Court that sought to bring Garcia back to the United States, but its spokespeople also insist on tarring Garcia as a “terrorist” and “human smuggler” in an escalating series of attacks on his character.
Other Republicans, it should be said, have backed the administration on this point, insisting that due process does not apply to undocumented or unauthorized immigrants. “When it comes to due process, that is a privilege reserved for American citizens,” Rep. Byron Donalds, R-Florida, a vocal ally of the president, said on NBC. Donalds should probably consult the Constitution, which makes no mention of citizenship or immigration status in either of the two amendments, the Fifth and the 14th, that guarantee the right of due process to all “persons.”
If the framers and ratifiers of these amendments had intended to differentiate between citizens and noncitizens, they would have done so. That is especially true for the authors of the 14th Amendment, who were preoccupied with questions of rights and citizenship, and who dealt with nativism and anti-immigrant sentiment within their political coalitions. They could have written a due process clause whose protection only went as far as native and naturalized citizens. They chose not to.
***
