He was not a philosopher MAGA would read, but he was also not a philosopher mainstream liberals would read. And not just because that would mean admitting they didn’t know as much as they thought and needed help in thinking more deeply — a fact about ourselves, to be fair, most of us don’t want to accept — but because he wouldn’t come down with a reassuring affirmation of the political binary by which American politics operates.
Alasdair MacIntyre was not a man who said “Go team!” He was a man who said, more than a little critically, “This is the wrong game.”
Why we can’t stop arguing
One of the world’s eminent philosophers, he grew up in Scotland and was educated and began teaching in England. He eventually moved to the United States, where he taught at many of our major universities, including Yale, Princeton, Brandeis, Duke and Notre Dame, where he wound up at the end of his career.
He had a great deal to say about a lot of subjects, and wrote a lot of substantial books, and I’ll leave it to the experts — he was a thinker who attracted lots of disciples and critics — to summarize his thinking. I’ll deal with just one aspect, one helping explain our political life.
